Overview
Chelsea Frost, aka Pie Girl, is a Hightstown baker who has been wowing New Jersey pie lovers with her unique, farm-fresh creations like salted honey lavender, chocolate-covered strawberry, cranberry chess and sweet corn custard. PieGirl is a small batch bakery.
Every weekend there is an assortment of pies and quiche, whole and by the slice, along with cakes, scones, muffins, cookies, cinnamon buns, fresh focaccia and other goodies. On Saturdays ONLY, Pie Girl offers savory galettes AND sandwiches on freshly baked bread - sandwiches start at 11:30 a.m. The menu changes every weekend, you’ll find the menu posted on Instagram on Thursday and Friday nights for the following day.
Best sellers are the Salted Honey Lavender, Strawberry Rhubarb and Sweet Jersey Corn Custard (when in season), a bright yellow buttermilk-based custard pie laced with pureed fresh Jersey corn. From tomato to corn, the pie selections take on what's growing on New Jersey's farms and what she's got at home. Curious for something even more unique, ask for the Sun Tea Pie, Black Tea & Rose Custard, Honey Lime Pistachio, Candy Bar pie and Passionfruit Custard.
HOURS
Fridays & Saturdays from 10 a.m. - 2:00-ish (or until sold out). The -ish is for the days that sell out a bit earlier, or unforeseen circumstances that time is needed outside of the pie shop.
Get Directions
